New York Vs Pennsylvania: How The Northeastern States Stack Up

New York and Pennsylvania are large, influential states located in the Northeastern region of the United States. Both states played pivotal roles in the founding of America and remain economic and cultural powerhouses today. From their diverse populations to their stunning landscapes, New York and Pennsylvania have much in common but also key differences that make each state unique.

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer to your question: While New York and Pennsylvania share similarities in geography, history and demographics, New York distinguishes itself with its enormous global city, while Pennsylvania is known for its role in colonial history and concentration of Amish communities.

Population and Demographics

New York has a much larger population at around 20 million vs. 13 million in Pennsylvania

When it comes to population, New York takes the lead with a significantly larger number of residents. With approximately 20 million people, it surpasses Pennsylvania’s population, which stands at around 13 million.

The higher population in New York can be attributed to various factors, including its status as a global economic hub and the presence of major cities such as New York City.

New York City skews NY’s demographics to be more diverse

One of the key factors that differentiate New York from Pennsylvania in terms of demographics is the diversity of its population. New York City, often referred to as the melting pot of cultures, plays a significant role in this.

The city is home to people from various ethnic backgrounds and nationalities, contributing to a rich tapestry of diversity. As a result, New York’s overall demographics are more diverse compared to Pennsylvania.

Pennsylvania has more Amish and Mennonite populations

While New York may have a larger overall population, Pennsylvania stands out for its unique demographics, particularly in terms of its Amish and Mennonite populations. The state is home to one of the largest Amish populations in the United States, primarily residing in Lancaster County and surrounding areas.

The Amish community’s commitment to traditional values and way of life adds a distinct cultural element to Pennsylvania’s demographics.

It’s worth noting that demographic data can change over time, so it’s always important to refer to the latest statistics for a comprehensive understanding of the population and demographics of both New York and Pennsylvania.

Economy and Industry

When it comes to the economy and industry, both New York and Pennsylvania have their own unique strengths and areas of expertise.

New York has a stronger finance, media, and tech presence in NYC

New York is home to one of the world’s financial capitals, New York City. With Wall Street at its heart, the state boasts a strong presence in the finance industry. The city is also a hub for media and entertainment, with major television networks, film studios, and publishing houses calling NYC their home.

Additionally, New York City has become a center for technology and innovation, attracting startups and tech giants alike. Companies like Google, Facebook, and Amazon have established offices in the city, contributing to its thriving tech sector.

Pennsylvania rivals with legacy manufacturing and energy industries

Pennsylvania, on the other hand, has a rich history in legacy manufacturing industries. From steel production in Pittsburgh to the coal and iron industries in various regions of the state, Pennsylvania has been a driving force in the manufacturing sector.

While the manufacturing industry has evolved over the years, Pennsylvania continues to have a strong presence in industries such as steel, chemicals, and machinery. Additionally, the state has a significant focus on the energy sector, particularly in natural gas extraction from the Marcellus Shale formation.

Agriculture is big business in PA while NY excels in services

When it comes to agriculture, Pennsylvania takes the lead. The state is known for its fertile farmlands and diverse agricultural products. From dairy farms to crop cultivation, Pennsylvania’s agriculture industry is a major contributor to the state’s economy.

On the other hand, New York excels in the services sector. With a strong emphasis on tourism, hospitality, and professional services, New York benefits from the bustling activity in its cities and the international appeal of destinations like New York City and the Finger Lakes region.

Geography and Climate

Both New York and Pennsylvania are northeastern states in the United States, sharing some similarities in terms of geography and climate. Both states have Great Lakes coastlines and mountainous upstate regions, offering stunning natural landscapes for outdoor enthusiasts.

New York’s Adirondack and Catskill Mountains vs. Pennsylvania’s Poconos

New York boasts the Adirondack and Catskill Mountains, which are famous for their breathtaking beauty and outdoor recreational opportunities. The Adirondack Mountains are known for their high peaks and pristine lakes, making them a popular destination for hiking, camping, and fishing.

The Catskill Mountains, on the other hand, are known for their picturesque waterfalls and dense forests, attracting nature lovers from all over the world.

Pennsylvania, on the other hand, is home to the Pocono Mountains, a popular vacation spot for those looking for a mountain getaway. The Poconos offer a wide range of activities, including skiing, snowboarding, hiking, and water sports.

With its charming resorts and scenic beauty, the Poconos are a favorite destination for both locals and tourists.

Climate is continental but Pennsylvania has colder winters

Both New York and Pennsylvania experience a continental climate, characterized by hot summers and cold winters. However, Pennsylvania tends to have colder winters compared to New York. This is mainly due to its geographical location and proximity to the Appalachian Mountains, which can cause colder air masses to settle over the state during the winter months.

In contrast, New York City and other coastal areas of New York tend to have milder winters due to the moderating influence of the Atlantic Ocean.

According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), the average winter temperature in Pennsylvania ranges from X to Y degrees Fahrenheit, while in New York, it ranges from A to B degrees Fahrenheit.

These variations in temperature can have a significant impact on the activities and lifestyle of the residents in each state during the winter season.

Politics and Government

New York leans liberal while Pennsylvania is a swing state

When it comes to politics, New York and Pennsylvania have distinct differences. New York is known for leaning more towards liberal ideologies, while Pennsylvania is considered a swing state. In presidential elections, New York consistently votes for Democratic candidates, with the state being a stronghold for the party.

On the other hand, Pennsylvania has a history of being a battleground state, with both Democratic and Republican candidates having a chance of winning. This makes the political landscape in these two states quite different.

New York has more representatives due to larger population

One of the factors that differentiates New York and Pennsylvania in terms of politics is their population size. New York is the fourth most populous state in the United States, while Pennsylvania is the fifth.

Due to its larger population, New York has more representatives in the House of Representatives compared to Pennsylvania. Currently, New York has 27 representatives, while Pennsylvania has 18. This gives New York more influence in national politics and a larger voice in shaping legislation and policy.

Pennsylvania known for being a political battleground state

Pennsylvania has gained a reputation for being a crucial swing state in presidential elections. This means that the state has a history of being closely contested between Democratic and Republican candidates.

Pennsylvania’s swing state status is due to its diverse population and varying political ideologies across different regions. The state has a mix of urban, suburban, and rural areas, with each having different political leanings.

As a result, candidates often focus their campaign efforts on Pennsylvania, knowing that winning the state could significantly impact the overall election outcome.

Culture and Lifestyle

New York City dominates NY’s fame while PA has more local flare

When it comes to culture and lifestyle, New York City takes the spotlight in New York State. With its iconic landmarks, vibrant arts scene, and diverse culinary offerings, the city has become a global symbol of culture and innovation.

From Broadway shows to world-class museums, there is always something exciting happening in the Big Apple. On the other hand, Pennsylvania has a more localized charm. Its smaller cities and towns showcase a rich history and a strong sense of community.

From the Amish countryside to the historic sites in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania offers a unique and authentic experience.

Sports fandoms differ, with NY supporting Yankees/Giants and PA favoring Eagles/Steelers

Sports play a significant role in the culture of both New York and Pennsylvania. In New York, the Yankees and Giants are the darlings of the city, with fans passionately cheering them on at every game.

The electric atmosphere of a Yankees game at Yankee Stadium or a Giants game at MetLife Stadium is truly unparalleled. On the other hand, Pennsylvania residents proudly support their own teams, with the Philadelphia Eagles and the Pittsburgh Steelers being the top favorites.

The fervor and loyalty of these fan bases can be witnessed at Lincoln Financial Field and Heinz Field, where the cheers and chants echo throughout the stadiums.

Pennsylvania has a more relaxed countryside culture vs. New York’s bustling urbanism

While New York is known for its fast-paced, bustling urban environment, Pennsylvania offers a more relaxed and laid-back countryside culture. The picturesque landscapes, rolling hills, and charming small towns of Pennsylvania provide a tranquil escape from the city life.

Residents and visitors can enjoy outdoor activities such as hiking, fishing, and exploring the scenic beauty of the state. On the other hand, New York’s urbanism offers a never-ending array of entertainment options, world-class dining establishments, and a vibrant nightlife that keeps the city buzzing 24/7.

According to a survey conducted by Travel + Leisure, New York City ranked as the 4th best city in the world for culture and lifestyle, while Philadelphia, Pennsylvania ranked 9th in the United States for its vibrant arts scene.


New York and Pennsylvania, despite bordering one another, have developed unique identities and differences along with their historical and demographic similarities. New York distinguishes itself with its enormous impact on global finance, media, and culture driven by New York City, while Pennsylvania remains planted in early American history and values. Yet both states offer a diversity of people, places and experiences that make the Northeast a dynamic, vibrant region unlike any other.

Similar Posts