San Francisco and New York City are two of the biggest cultural and economic hubs in the United States. From their famous landmarks to their thriving job markets, these coastal cities both have a lot to offer residents and visitors alike. But how do they really compare when looking at factors like cost of living, transportation, job opportunities, and lifestyle?

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer: While both cities are expensive places to live with strong job markets and diverse cultures, San Francisco has a more laidback vibe compared to the fast pace of New York City. New York is significantly larger and has more extensive public transit, while San Francisco’s compact size makes it easier to get around by foot, bike or car.

Size and Geography


When it comes to population, both San Francisco and New York City are major urban centers with a significant number of residents. As of 2021, San Francisco has an estimated population of around 883,305 people, while New York City boasts a much larger population of approximately 8.4 million people.

The Big Apple is undoubtedly one of the most densely populated cities in the United States, attracting people from all walks of life.

Land Area

When comparing the land area of these two iconic cities, San Francisco is significantly smaller in size than New York City. San Francisco covers approximately 46.87 square miles, whereas New York City spans over 302.6 square miles.

Despite its smaller size, San Francisco is known for its hilly terrain, iconic landmarks like the Golden Gate Bridge, and its unique neighborhoods such as Chinatown and Haight-Ashbury.


The climates of San Francisco and New York City differ greatly due to their geographical locations. San Francisco is known for its mild and temperate Mediterranean climate, characterized by cool summers and wet winters.

On the other hand, New York City experiences a humid subtropical climate, with hot and humid summers and cold winters. Both cities offer residents and visitors a diverse range of weather patterns throughout the year.

Regional Location

San Francisco is located on the west coast of the United States in the state of California. It is known for its beautiful coastline, proximity to the Silicon Valley, and its vibrant tech industry. On the other hand, New York City is situated on the east coast in the state of New York.

It serves as a global hub for finance, fashion, and the arts, attracting people from all over the world.

For more information on San Francisco, you can visit the official website of the City and County of San Francisco. To learn more about New York City, you can explore the official website of New York City.

Economy and Job Market

Major Industries

San Francisco and New York City have robust and diverse economies with strengths in different key industries.

San Francisco is world-famous as a tech and innovation hub. Major companies like Facebook, Google, Twitter, Uber, and Airbnb are headquartered in the city. Other big industries are finance, tourism, and healthcare.New York City is a leader in finance, media, real estate, healthcare, tourism, and retail. Major stock exchanges, investment banks, media conglomerates, and retailers have headquarters in NYC.

Both cities benefit from concentrations of top talent and capital that feed innovation and business growth across many sectors.

Unemployment Rates

In recent years, unemployment has been remarkably low in both metro areas:

San Francisco 2.9%
New York City 5.0%

These rates were pre-pandemic. The COVID-19 crisis caused spikes in unemployment as business activity slowed. However, employment has largely recovered in these major hubs with diversified economies.

Average Salaries

Due to high costs of living, wages are also higher in these cities compared to national averages. As of 2021, average salaries were:

San Francisco $103,557
New York City $82,459

However, these high salaries do not necessarily mean better purchasing power. Housing and other costs are far above U.S. averages, consuming more income.

Housing and Cost of Living

Home Prices

When it comes to home prices, both San Francisco and New York City are notorious for being some of the most expensive cities in the United States. In San Francisco, the median home price is currently around $1.4 million, according to Zillow.

Meanwhile, in New York City, the median home price is slightly higher, hovering around $1.6 million, as reported by Zillow. These sky-high prices can be attributed to factors such as the limited supply of housing and the high demand from residents and investors alike.

Rent Prices

Renting a place in either San Francisco or New York City is also quite expensive. In San Francisco, the average monthly rent for a one-bedroom apartment is approximately $3,500, while a two-bedroom apartment can cost around $4,500 per month.

Similarly, in New York City, the average monthly rent for a one-bedroom apartment is about $3,200, with a two-bedroom apartment costing around $4,500 per month. These rental prices are significantly higher compared to the national average, making it challenging for many individuals to find affordable housing in these cities.

Overall Cost of Living

The overall cost of living in both San Francisco and New York City is considerably higher compared to other parts of the country. From groceries to transportation and entertainment, residents in these cities can expect to spend a significant portion of their income on daily expenses.

According to the Numbeo cost of living index, San Francisco ranks as the 2nd most expensive city in the United States, while New York City holds the 3rd spot. These rankings take into account factors such as housing, transportation, groceries, and restaurant prices.

It is important to note that while the cost of living may be high in both San Francisco and New York City, these cities also offer a plethora of job opportunities, cultural experiences, and vibrant communities.

Many individuals are willing to pay a premium for the unique lifestyle and opportunities that these iconic cities provide.

Transportation and Commuting

Public Transportation Systems

Both San Francisco and New York City boast extensive and efficient public transportation systems, making it easy for residents and visitors to navigate the cities without the need for a car. In San Francisco, the Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART) system provides subway and train services, while the iconic cable cars offer a unique way to get around the city.

Additionally, buses and ferries are available for transportation within and outside the city.

New York City, on the other hand, is known for its subway system, which is one of the oldest and largest in the world. With its vast network of subway lines and buses, getting from one neighborhood to another is a breeze.

The Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) operates the subway system, and it serves millions of commuters on a daily basis.

When it comes to public transportation, both cities offer reliable and convenient options, but New York City’s extensive subway system gives it a slight edge over San Francisco.

Traffic and Commute Times

As bustling metropolises, both San Francisco and New York City experience heavy traffic congestion during peak hours. However, New York City is notorious for its gridlocked streets, especially in Manhattan.

The city’s high population density and limited parking options contribute to the challenging commute for drivers.

In contrast, San Francisco’s traffic is less intense compared to New York City, but it still has its fair share of congestion, particularly during rush hours. The city’s hilly terrain and narrow streets can pose challenges for drivers, but public transportation options are readily available to alleviate some of the traffic woes.

When comparing commute times, it’s important to consider the distance traveled. New York City’s extensive subway system allows for relatively faster commutes within the city, while longer distances may take more time due to traffic.

In San Francisco, commuting times can vary depending on the location and mode of transportation, but the city’s smaller size generally results in shorter travel times.


Both San Francisco and New York City are known for their walkability, with vibrant neighborhoods and numerous attractions within walking distance. In San Francisco, areas like Fisherman’s Wharf, Union Square, and the Mission District offer pedestrian-friendly streets lined with shops, restaurants, and landmarks.

New York City, with its distinct neighborhoods like SoHo, Greenwich Village, and Times Square, also provides ample opportunities for exploration on foot. The city’s grid-like layout and bustling streets make it easy for pedestrians to navigate and discover hidden gems around every corner.

According to a study conducted by Walk Score, a website that measures walkability, both San Francisco and New York City rank among the top cities in the United States for walkability. San Francisco has a walk score of 87, while New York City has a walk score of 89, indicating that both cities are highly pedestrian-friendly.

Culture and Lifestyle

Both San Francisco and New York City are known for their vibrant cultures and diverse lifestyles. Each city has its unique charm and offers a wide range of experiences for residents and visitors alike.


When it comes to diversity, both cities excel. San Francisco prides itself on its multicultural population, with over 35% of its residents being Asian-American and 15% being Hispanic or Latino. The city is also known for its strong LGBTQ+ community, making it one of the most inclusive cities in the world.

New York City, on the other hand, is a melting pot of cultures, with over 36% of its residents being foreign-born. The city is home to people from all walks of life, making it a truly global city.

Food Scene

Both San Francisco and New York City boast incredible food scenes that cater to all taste buds. San Francisco is famous for its farm-to-table movement and its emphasis on fresh, local ingredients. The city is known for its seafood, particularly its Dungeness crab and clam chowder.

New York City, on the other hand, is a food lover’s paradise, with a diverse range of cuisines from around the world. From street food to Michelin-starred restaurants, the city offers something for every palate.


When it comes to nightlife, both cities have their own unique offerings. San Francisco is known for its vibrant music scene, with live music venues ranging from intimate jazz clubs to large concert halls. The city also has a thriving bar scene, with plenty of trendy cocktail bars and speakeasies.

New York City, on the other hand, is famous for its iconic nightlife, with world-class nightclubs, Broadway shows, and a bustling bar scene that never sleeps. The city truly comes alive after dark.

Outdoor Activities

Both San Francisco and New York City offer a plethora of outdoor activities for those who love to explore the great outdoors. San Francisco is blessed with its proximity to nature, with beautiful parks such as Golden Gate Park and stunning views from Twin Peaks.

The city is also a paradise for outdoor enthusiasts, with opportunities for hiking, biking, and surfing. New York City, on the other hand, may be known for its skyscrapers, but it also has its fair share of green spaces.

Central Park is a haven for joggers, cyclists, and picnickers, while the Hudson River offers opportunities for kayaking and sailing.


While both amazing cities in their own right, San Francisco and New York City offer very different lifestyles. New York’s sheer size and nonstop energy contrast with laidback San Francisco’s compact footprint. But both cities provide tremendous job opportunities, world-class culture and entertainment, and access to outdoor spaces – offering something for everyone.

Similar Posts