The story of Major League Baseball’s San Francisco Giants is an interesting tale of franchise relocation that brought baseball to the West Coast. If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer to your question: The New York Giants baseball team officially moved to San Francisco for the 1958 MLB season after owner Horace Stoneham announced the relocation in 1957.

In this approximately 3000 word article, we will take an in-depth look at the history of the Giants franchise, the factors that led them to leave New York after over seven decades, the negotiations to bring MLB to the Bay Area, and the Giants’ first seasons playing in San Francisco in their new home at Seals Stadium and later Candlestick Park.

The Giants in New York

The New York Giants, now known as the San Francisco Giants, have a rich history that dates back to the late 19th century. The team was founded in 1883 as the New York Gothams and later changed their name to the Giants in 1885.

For over 70 years, the Giants called New York City their home and became one of the most iconic teams in Major League Baseball.

Early History and Success

The Giants had a strong start in New York, winning their first National League pennant in 1888 and going on to win five World Series titles in the early 1900s. Led by legendary players such as Christy Mathewson, John McGraw, and Mel Ott, the Giants were a dominant force in baseball and were known for their fierce rivalry with the Brooklyn Dodgers.

During this era, the Giants played their home games at several stadiums in New York, including the Polo Grounds and the Baker Bowl. These stadiums were filled with passionate fans who cheered on their beloved Giants and witnessed some of the greatest moments in baseball history.

The Struggling Years

In the 1930s and 1940s, the Giants experienced a period of decline on the field. Despite the struggles, the team still had standout players like Carl Hubbell and Mel Ott, but they were unable to regain their winning ways.

The Giants finished in the lower half of the National League standings during this time, and attendance at their games began to decline.

However, the tide started to turn in the 1950s with the arrival of a young outfielder named Willie Mays. Mays quickly became a superstar and helped revive the Giants’ fortunes. The team had several successful seasons in the late 1950s, including winning the National League pennant in 1951 and 1954.

Failed Attempts to Move the Franchise

Despite their success on the field, the Giants faced financial challenges in New York. The team’s owners, Horace Stoneham and Charles Stoneham, explored the possibility of moving the franchise to other cities that were offering better stadium deals and financial incentives.

One notable failed attempt to move the Giants was in 1957 when the team considered relocating to Minneapolis. However, the proposal was ultimately rejected by the other National League owners, and the Giants remained in New York for several more years.

In the early 1960s, the Giants once again contemplated a move, this time to San Francisco. The city’s mayor, George Christopher, and other local officials worked tirelessly to convince the team to make the move to the West Coast.

In 1958, the Giants finally announced their relocation to San Francisco, marking the end of their era in New York.

Today, the San Francisco Giants continue to build on the legacy of their time in New York, honoring their history while creating new memories for their fans in the Bay Area.

The Move to California

When did the Giants move to San Francisco? The Giants, originally based in New York City, made their move to the Golden State in 1958. This relocation marked a major turning point in the history of the franchise.

Reasons for Relocation

There were several reasons that led to the Giants’ decision to move to California. Firstly, the team’s attendance had been declining in New York, primarily due to competition from the more successful Yankees.

Additionally, the aging Polo Grounds, where the Giants played their home games, was in need of significant repairs and renovations.

Another factor was the allure of the booming West Coast market. The Giants saw an opportunity to tap into a new fan base and potentially increase their revenue by moving to California. The prospect of playing in a state known for its beautiful weather and strong economy was certainly enticing.

Furthermore, the emergence of television as a popular medium played a role in the relocation. California was seen as a prime location for televised games, as it would allow the Giants to reach a larger audience and potentially attract more sponsors.

Stoneham’s Deal with San Francisco

Once the decision to move was made, Giants owner Horace Stoneham began searching for a suitable new home for the team. After considering several cities, including Minneapolis and Toronto, Stoneham ultimately struck a deal with San Francisco.

The city of San Francisco was eager to bring a Major League Baseball team to the area, and they offered the Giants a favorable stadium deal. The city agreed to build a new stadium, Candlestick Park, which would serve as the team’s new home.

This agreement, along with other financial incentives, convinced Stoneham to make the move.

On September 15, 1957, the Giants’ move to San Francisco was officially announced. The news was met with mixed reactions from fans in both New York and California. While some were saddened by the loss of their beloved team, others were excited about the prospect of having a Major League franchise in their city.

In the end, the move to San Francisco proved to be a successful one for the Giants. The team found new success on the West Coast, winning several National League pennants and capturing three World Series titles in the span of five years in the 2010s.

For more information about the Giants’ move to San Francisco, you can visit

The Giants Arrive in San Francisco

When the New York Giants made the bold decision to relocate to the West Coast, it marked a significant moment in both baseball and San Francisco history. The team’s move to San Francisco in 1958 was driven by a desire to tap into the booming population and economic growth of California.

This decision not only transformed the Giants into a truly national team, but it also paved the way for the expansion of baseball on the West Coast.

First Years at Seals Stadium

Upon their arrival in San Francisco, the Giants played their home games at Seals Stadium, a minor league ballpark located in the city’s Mission District. While Seals Stadium had its charm, it was clear that a larger and more modern stadium was needed to accommodate the growing fan base.

Despite the challenges of playing in a temporary home, the Giants quickly became a beloved team in San Francisco, with fans flocking to see the likes of Willie Mays, Willie McCovey, and Juan Marichal in action.

The Building of Candlestick Park

In the early 1960s, plans were set in motion to construct a state-of-the-art stadium for the Giants. The result was Candlestick Park, a multi-purpose stadium located in the city’s Bayview Heights neighborhood.

Opening its doors in 1960, Candlestick Park became the new home of the Giants and would serve as their iconic venue for over four decades. The stadium’s unique architecture, characterized by its cold winds and swirling fog, created a challenging environment for players but also added to its mystique.

Fun fact: Did you know that the Beatles played their last live concert at Candlestick Park in 1966?

New Rivals and Opponents on the West Coast

The Giants’ move to San Francisco not only brought a new team to the city but also introduced new rivalries and opponents on the West Coast. The Los Angeles Dodgers, who had also recently relocated from Brooklyn, became the Giants’ primary rivals, igniting a fierce and storied rivalry that continues to this day.

The Giants’ presence in San Francisco also led to the birth of new rivalries with other West Coast teams, such as the San Diego Padres and the Seattle Mariners.

For more information about the history of the San Francisco Giants, you can visit their official website:


The story of the Giants’ move from New York to San Francisco over six decades ago was a major milestone in baseball history. While leaving behind a long history in New York, the franchise found new life in California and has built a strong new fan culture in their adopted Bay Area home. The legacy of the Giants’ relocation continues to shape Major League Baseball today as part of baseball’s expansion to a nationwide sport.

Similar Posts