Two Teams For One City: Examining New York’S Yankees And Mets

As one of only two cities in MLB with multiple baseball teams, New York holds a unique status in professional sports. Both the Yankees and the Mets call the Big Apple home. But why exactly does New York have two Major League Baseball teams?

If you’re short on time, here’s a quick answer: New York has historically had the population, fan base, and money to support two MLB teams – initially the Giants and Dodgers and now the Yankees and Mets.

In this approximately 3000 word article, we’ll dive into the history of baseball in New York and the factors that allowed two teams to emerge and thrive. We’ll look at early NYC baseball, the rise and relocation of the Giants and Dodgers, and the void left that the Mets and an expanded Yankees franchise filled. We’ll also examine the cultural identities that have grown around each team.

The Deep Roots of Baseball in New York City

New York City is widely regarded as the birthplace of baseball and has a rich history deeply intertwined with the sport. From its early days in the 19th century to the establishment of major league teams, such as the Yankees and Mets, the city has always been a hub for baseball enthusiasts and players alike.

New York’s 19th Century Baseball League

In the mid-1800s, New York City was home to one of the first organized baseball leagues in the country. The New York Knickerbocker Base Ball Club, founded in 1845, played a crucial role in formalizing the rules of the game and popularizing it among the masses.

The club’s influence extended beyond New York, as their rules became the basis for the modern game of baseball.

As the sport gained popularity, more teams started to emerge in the city, leading to the formation of the National Association of Base Ball Players in 1857. This league paved the way for the professionalization of the sport and set the stage for the future major league teams that would call New York home.

The New York Giants and the Origins of Major League Baseball

In the late 19th century, the New York Giants became one of the founding members of the National League, the precursor to modern Major League Baseball. The Giants, led by legendary players like John McGraw and Christy Mathewson, were a dominant force in the league, winning numerous pennants and World Series titles.

The Giants’ success not only solidified New York City’s place as a baseball powerhouse but also set the stage for the fierce rivalry that would develop with another New York team in the years to come.

The Dodgers Arrive from Brooklyn

In 1957, the Brooklyn Dodgers, one of New York City’s beloved teams, made the historic move to Los Angeles. This departure left a void in the city’s baseball scene, but it also opened up an opportunity for a new team to take its place.

Enter the New York Mets. Formed in 1962, the Mets were created to fill the void left by the Dodgers and the Giants. The team quickly gained a loyal following and became an integral part of New York’s baseball landscape.

The Mets’ World Series victories in 1969 and 1986 further solidified their place in the hearts of New Yorkers.

Today, both the Yankees and Mets continue to thrive in New York City, providing fans with exciting baseball action and a sense of pride in their city’s deep-rooted baseball history.

For more information about the history of baseball in New York City, you can visit the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum website.

The Giants and Dodgers Leave New York

Once upon a time, New York City was home to not one but two iconic baseball teams – the New York Giants and the Brooklyn Dodgers. These teams were deeply rooted in the hearts of New Yorkers and had a rich history of success and rivalry.

However, all good things must come to an end, and in the mid-1950s, both the Giants and the Dodgers made a monumental decision to leave the Big Apple.

Westward Expansion of MLB

One of the main reasons behind the departure of the Giants and the Dodgers was the westward expansion of Major League Baseball (MLB). In the 1950s, baseball was gaining popularity in California, and the league saw an opportunity to tap into this new market.

The Giants and the Dodgers, both facing financial challenges, saw the move as a chance to increase revenue and reach a wider fan base.

With the promise of new stadiums and the allure of the sunny West Coast, the Giants packed their bags and moved to San Francisco in 1958. The Dodgers followed suit in 1957, making Los Angeles their new home.

This marked the end of an era for New York City, as the two teams that had brought so much joy and excitement to the city for decades were no longer a part of its sports landscape.

Losing Two Iconic Teams

The departure of the Giants and the Dodgers was a devastating blow to New York City. The loss of these two iconic teams left a void in the hearts of baseball fans and had a significant impact on the city’s sports culture.

The rivalry between the Giants and the Dodgers had been fierce, with numerous memorable moments and heated battles on the field. The absence of these teams meant that New York City was left without a true baseball rivalry for many years.

Furthermore, the departure of the Giants and the Dodgers also had an economic impact on the city. Baseball games were not just about the competition on the field; they were also a source of revenue for local businesses.

The absence of these teams meant fewer games, fewer fans, and ultimately, fewer dollars flowing into the local economy.

The Push for National League Expansion

The loss of the Giants and the Dodgers left a void in New York City’s baseball scene, and it didn’t take long for efforts to bring a new team to the city to begin. The push for National League expansion gained momentum, and in 1962, the New York Mets were born.

The Mets became the new team for New Yorkers to rally behind, and although they struggled in their early years, they eventually found success, winning the World Series in 1969 and 1986.

Today, the New York Yankees and the New York Mets coexist in the city, providing fans with two unique and distinct baseball experiences. The Yankees, with their storied history and numerous championships, continue to be one of the most successful and popular teams in MLB.

The Mets, on the other hand, have carved out their own niche and have a dedicated fan base that supports them through thick and thin.

While the departure of the Giants and the Dodgers was undoubtedly a loss for New York City, it paved the way for the birth of the Mets and the continued passion for baseball in the city. The rivalry between the Yankees and the Mets may not be as intense as the one between the Giants and the Dodgers, but it still adds an element of excitement to the city’s sports scene.

A New New York Mets Franchise

The birth of the New York Mets franchise was a result of a successful bid to bring a new baseball team to the city. With the popularity of the New York Yankees dominating the baseball scene, there was a desire for a second team to provide competition and give fans more options.

The bid to establish the Mets was won by a group of investors led by Joan Whitney Payson, who became the team’s first majority owner.

Winning an Expansion Team Bid

In 1957, the National League announced its intention to expand by adding two new teams. Several cities submitted bids, including New York. The bid by the Payson-led group was successful, and on October 17, 1960, the New York Mets were officially awarded an expansion franchise.

This marked the return of National League baseball to New York since the departure of the Brooklyn Dodgers and New York Giants in 1957.

Building Shea Stadium in Queens

With the franchise secured, the next step was to find a suitable location for the team’s home stadium. The decision was made to build Shea Stadium in the borough of Queens. Construction began in 1962, and the stadium was completed in time for the Mets’ inaugural season in 1964.

Shea Stadium became the Mets’ home for over four decades, hosting many memorable moments and becoming an iconic symbol of the team.

Forming a New Fanbase

As a new franchise, the Mets had the challenge of building a fanbase from scratch. The team worked hard to connect with the diverse population of New York City and create a sense of community. They introduced promotions, special events, and initiatives to engage fans and make attending games a memorable experience.

Over time, the Mets gained a dedicated following, with fans affectionately calling themselves “Amazins” and rallying behind the team through highs and lows.

Today, the New York Mets continue to be a beloved part of the city’s sports culture, with a passionate fanbase that supports the team through thick and thin. Their rivalry with the New York Yankees adds to the excitement of the baseball scene in New York City, making it a unique and dynamic sports landscape.

The Yankees Dynasty Captures NYC

The New York Yankees have long been synonymous with dominance and success in Major League Baseball. With a rich history dating back to the early 1900s, the Yankees have captured the hearts of fans across the city and beyond.

Their success has been built on a foundation of talented players, iconic stadiums, and a legacy that continues to inspire new generations of baseball enthusiasts.

Babe Ruth and Yankee Stadium

No discussion of the Yankees dynasty would be complete without mentioning the legendary Babe Ruth. Known as the “Sultan of Swat,” Ruth was a larger-than-life figure who revolutionized the game of baseball.

His remarkable home run record, charismatic personality, and larger-than-life presence helped to establish the Yankees as a force to be reckoned with.

One of the key factors that contributed to the Yankees’ success was the construction of Yankee Stadium in 1923. This iconic ballpark, often referred to as “The House That Ruth Built,” became the home of the Yankees and provided a fitting stage for their dominance.

With its grand architecture and historic significance, Yankee Stadium became a symbol of the team’s success and a beloved landmark for fans.

Dominance and Legacy

The Yankees’ dynasty reached its peak during the 1940s and 1950s, when the team won an unprecedented five consecutive World Series championships from 1949 to 1953. Led by legendary players such as Joe DiMaggio, Mickey Mantle, and Yogi Berra, the Yankees became a powerhouse in the world of baseball.

This era of dominance laid the foundation for the Yankees’ lasting legacy. The team’s continued success in subsequent decades, including championships in the 1970s, 1990s, and early 2000s, solidified their status as one of the most successful franchises in all of sports.

The Yankees as New York’s American League Team

In addition to their on-field success, the Yankees have also established themselves as New York City’s premier American League team. With a fan base that spans generations and a history that is deeply intertwined with the city’s culture, the Yankees have become an integral part of New York’s sports identity.

While the city also has a National League team, the New York Mets, the Yankees have consistently overshadowed their crosstown rivals. The Yankees’ success, combined with their historic ties to the city, has solidified their position as New York’s team in the American League.

For more information on the New York Yankees and their storied history, visit

Two Established NYC Baseball Cultures

When it comes to baseball in New York City, there are two iconic teams that have carved out their own unique identities: the New York Yankees and the New York Mets. These teams represent more than just a game; they embody the spirit and culture of the city itself.

With a rich history and passionate fanbases, the Yankees and Mets have become an integral part of New York’s sports landscape.

The Working Class Mets, The Elite Yankees

The Mets and Yankees may both call New York home, but they couldn’t be more different in terms of their origins and fanbases. The Mets, affectionately known as the “Amazin’ Mets,” were established in 1962 as a team for the blue-collar working-class New Yorkers.

They quickly gained popularity, capturing the hearts of fans who identified with their underdog status. On the other hand, the Yankees have a long and storied history dating back to 1903. With their record 27 World Series championships and a roster filled with legendary players, the Yankees have earned a reputation as the elite team of New York.

Overlapping Yet Distinct Fanbases

While there is some overlap between Yankees and Mets fans, each team has its own dedicated and passionate following. Yankees fans are often seen as more traditional and nostalgic, cherishing the team’s history and success.

They proudly wear their pinstripes and can be found at Yankee Stadium, cheering on their beloved team with unwavering loyalty. On the other hand, Mets fans are known for their resilience and unwavering support, even during periods of struggle.

They bring a unique energy to Citi Field, waving their orange and blue flags and rallying behind their team, no matter the outcome.

Interesting fact: Did you know that in 2000, both the Yankees and Mets made it to the World Series, creating an unprecedented “Subway Series” between the two teams? It was an exciting time for baseball fans in New York, and the city was buzzing with anticipation and rivalry.

Coexisting in the Baseball Capital

New York City is often referred to as the “Baseball Capital” of the world, and it’s easy to see why. The presence of both the Yankees and Mets adds to the city’s vibrant sports culture, offering fans a choice between two distinct baseball experiences.

Whether you’re a die-hard Yankees fan or a loyal Mets supporter, there’s no shortage of excitement and rivalry in the Big Apple.

For more information about the New York Yankees, visit To learn more about the New York Mets, visit


While other major cities have lost teams, New York’s immense population, resources, and passion for baseball have sustained two Major League teams for over half a century. The Yankees and Mets now anchor separate, deeply rooted baseball cultures in the city. For true MLB fans in New York, having two home teams to root for provides double the enjoyment.

Similar Posts