Ranking The Boroughs Of New York City

New York City’s five boroughs each have their own unique character and appeal. If you’re wondering how they compare, here’s a quick answer for ranking New York’s boroughs from best to worst: Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, The Bronx, and Staten Island. In this comprehensive guide, we will explore what makes each borough great including culture, dining, nightlife, affordability, safety, transportation and more. We will also highlight some of the key positives and potential drawbacks of living in each NYC borough.

Ranking Criteria

When it comes to ranking the boroughs of New York City, several key factors come into play. These factors help to determine the overall quality of life and desirability of each borough. Let’s take a closer look at the criteria used to rank the boroughs.

Culture and entertainment options

New York City is known for its vibrant cultural scene and abundance of entertainment options. The boroughs are evaluated based on the variety and quality of museums, theaters, art galleries, music venues, and other cultural attractions they offer.

Boroughs with a rich cultural heritage and a wide range of entertainment options tend to rank higher in this category.

Dining and nightlife scene

The dining and nightlife scene is an important aspect of any city’s ranking. The boroughs are evaluated based on the diversity and quality of restaurants, cafes, bars, and clubs they have to offer. Boroughs with a thriving food scene and a vibrant nightlife tend to score well in this category.

Affordability of housing

The affordability of housing is a significant factor for many people when choosing where to live. The boroughs are evaluated based on the cost of rent or real estate prices, as well as the availability of affordable housing options.

Boroughs that offer a range of housing options at various price points rank higher in this category.

Public transportation access

New York City is known for its extensive public transportation system. The boroughs are evaluated based on the accessibility and reliability of public transportation options, such as subways, buses, and trains. Boroughs with easy access to public transportation tend to rank higher in this category.

Employment opportunities

Employment opportunities are a crucial consideration for many individuals when deciding where to live. The boroughs are evaluated based on the availability of jobs, the diversity of industries, and the overall economic climate.

Boroughs with a strong job market and a wide range of employment opportunities tend to score well in this category.

Crime rates and safety

The safety and security of a neighborhood are paramount for residents. The boroughs are evaluated based on crime rates, police presence, and overall safety measures in place. Boroughs with low crime rates and a strong sense of safety tend to rank higher in this category.

Parks and outdoor spaces

New York City is not just about skyscrapers and concrete. The boroughs are evaluated based on the availability and quality of parks, green spaces, and recreational facilities. Boroughs with well-maintained parks and ample outdoor spaces for residents to enjoy tend to score well in this category.

It is important to note that each individual’s priorities and preferences may vary. What may be important to one person may not hold the same weight for another. Therefore, when ranking the boroughs of New York City, it is crucial to consider the specific needs and preferences of each individual.

#1 Manhattan

When it comes to ranking the boroughs of New York City, Manhattan undoubtedly takes the top spot. With its iconic skyline and bustling streets, this borough is a world unto itself. Let’s explore why Manhattan is considered the crown jewel of the Big Apple.

World-class dining and entertainment

Manhattan offers a plethora of dining options that cater to every palate. From Michelin-starred restaurants to food trucks, you can find it all here. The borough is also home to some of the most renowned Broadway theaters, where you can catch a mesmerizing show.

Whether you’re a foodie or a theater enthusiast, Manhattan has something to offer.

Epicenter of arts and culture

Manhattan is the epicenter of arts and culture in New York City. It houses world-famous museums like the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the Museum of Modern Art, showcasing a vast collection of artistic masterpieces.

The borough also hosts numerous art galleries, attracting artists and art enthusiasts from all over the world. If you’re looking to immerse yourself in the vibrant art scene, Manhattan is the place to be.

Most subway lines and transportation access

Manhattan boasts the most extensive subway system in New York City, making it incredibly convenient to travel within the borough and to other parts of the city. With a multitude of subway lines crisscrossing Manhattan, you can easily reach your destination in no time.

This accessibility is a significant advantage for residents and visitors alike.

Amazing parks like Central Park

Central Park, spanning over 840 acres, is the crown jewel of Manhattan’s green spaces. It offers a serene oasis in the heart of the bustling city, where visitors can enjoy picnics, bike rides, or leisurely strolls.

The park’s lush landscapes and iconic landmarks make it a must-visit destination for locals and tourists alike.

High cost of living and housing

While Manhattan offers unparalleled opportunities and amenities, it also comes with a high cost of living. The borough’s prime location and desirability drive up housing prices, making it one of the most expensive places to live in the city.

Renting or owning property in Manhattan requires a significant financial commitment. However, for those who can afford it, the rewards of living in this vibrant borough are truly unparalleled.

#2 Brooklyn

Brooklyn, the second largest borough of New York City, is a vibrant and diverse neighborhood that offers a unique blend of history, culture, and entertainment. It is no wonder that Brooklyn has become a popular destination for both locals and tourists alike.

Hipster culture in Williamsburg and Bushwick

One of the main draws of Brooklyn is its thriving hipster culture, particularly in the neighborhoods of Williamsburg and Bushwick. With their trendy cafes, vintage shops, and street art, these areas have become synonymous with Brooklyn’s cool and creative vibe.

You can easily spend an entire day exploring the unique shops, enjoying delicious food from local artisans, and immersing yourself in the vibrant atmosphere.

Cool foodie neighborhoods like Carroll Gardens

Brooklyn is also known for its diverse culinary scene. Neighborhoods like Carroll Gardens are a food lover’s paradise, offering a wide array of restaurants, cafes, and food markets. From trendy farm-to-table eateries to traditional pizzerias, there is something to satisfy every palate.

Don’t miss the chance to try some of Brooklyn’s famous artisanal ice cream or indulge in a classic New York-style bagel.

More affordable than Manhattan

One of the major advantages of living or staying in Brooklyn is that it is generally more affordable than Manhattan. While Manhattan is known for its sky-high rents and expensive cost of living, Brooklyn offers a more budget-friendly alternative without compromising on quality of life.

Whether you are looking for a place to live, dine, or shop, Brooklyn provides great value for your money.

Accessible by many subway lines

Getting around Brooklyn is a breeze, thanks to its extensive subway network. The borough is served by multiple subway lines, making it easy to explore different neighborhoods and attractions. Whether you want to visit the iconic Coney Island, catch a concert at the Barclays Center, or simply enjoy a leisurely stroll along the Brooklyn Heights Promenade, the subway provides convenient access to all corners of the borough.

Farther from main tourist attractions

While Brooklyn has a lot to offer, it is important to note that it is farther from the main tourist attractions in Manhattan. If you are primarily interested in visiting landmarks like Times Square, Central Park, or the Empire State Building, you may need to factor in some extra travel time.

However, with its own unique charm and attractions, Brooklyn is definitely worth exploring for a truly authentic New York experience.

#3 Queens

Queens, the largest borough in New York City, offers a unique blend of ethnic diversity and amazing global cuisine. With over 138 languages spoken, Queens is a melting pot of cultures, making it a food lover’s paradise.

From authentic Chinese dumplings in Flushing to mouthwatering Greek souvlaki in Astoria, Queens has something to satisfy every palate. The borough’s diverse culinary scene has gained recognition from food critics and has even been featured in popular food shows like “Anthony Bourdain: Parts Unknown.”

Ethnic diversity and amazing global cuisine

Queens is home to a vibrant immigrant community, which has contributed to its rich cultural tapestry. The borough boasts a wide range of ethnic enclaves, including Little India in Jackson Heights, Little Manila in Woodside, and Little Guyana in Richmond Hill.

These neighborhoods offer an authentic taste of their respective cultures, with bustling markets, traditional festivals, and, of course, delicious food. Whether you’re craving spicy Indian curry or savory Jamaican jerk chicken, Queens has it all.

Much more affordable housing than Manhattan and Brooklyn

One of the biggest advantages of living in Queens is its affordability compared to Manhattan and Brooklyn. While housing prices in those boroughs continue to skyrocket, Queens offers a more budget-friendly option for residents.

Whether you’re looking for a spacious apartment or a cozy single-family home, Queens has a variety of housing options to suit different budgets. Additionally, the borough’s diverse neighborhoods provide a unique living experience, from the upscale homes of Forest Hills to the vibrant streets of Jackson Heights.

Easy transportation on subway and LIRR

Queens is well-connected to the rest of New York City through its extensive public transportation system. The borough is served by several subway lines, including the 7, E, F, M, R, and N trains, making it easy to commute to Manhattan or other parts of Queens.

Additionally, Queens is also served by the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR), which provides a convenient option for those traveling to Long Island or other parts of the city. With multiple transportation options, getting around Queens and beyond is a breeze.

World-class museums and performing arts at Flushing Meadows Corona Park

Flushing Meadows Corona Park, located in Queens, is home to several world-class attractions, including the Queens Museum and the USTA Billie Jean King National Tennis Center. The Queens Museum is renowned for its collection of contemporary art and its iconic Panorama of the City of New York, a massive scale model of the city.

The USTA Billie Jean King National Tennis Center hosts the annual US Open, one of the most prestigious tennis tournaments in the world. With its cultural institutions and sporting events, Flushing Meadows Corona Park offers something for everyone.

Far from Midtown and downtown Manhattan tourist sights

While some may see the distance from Midtown and downtown Manhattan as a drawback, it can also be seen as an advantage. Living in Queens allows residents to escape the hustle and bustle of the tourist-filled areas and enjoy a more relaxed pace of life.

However, this doesn’t mean that Queens lacks its own attractions. From the picturesque waterfront of Long Island City to the historic sites of Jamaica, Queens has its own unique charm and plenty of hidden gems waiting to be discovered.

#4 The Bronx

The Bronx, known as the “Borough of Parks,” offers a unique mix of urban living and outdoor spaces. It is home to the legendary New York Yankees, one of the most successful sports franchises in history.

Baseball fans can catch a game at the iconic Yankee Stadium and experience the electric atmosphere that comes with it. The Bronx also boasts other great sports teams and venues, such as the Fordham Rams basketball team and the Pelham Bay Park Tennis Courts.

The New York Yankees and great sports

Aside from its sports history, the Bronx is also famous for its iconic attractions. Nature enthusiasts can explore the Bronx Zoo, one of the largest metropolitan zoos in the world, where they can encounter a wide variety of animals.

The New York Botanical Garden is another must-visit spot, with its stunning displays of plant life and beautiful landscapes. These attractions make the Bronx a great destination for families, nature lovers, and anyone looking for a unique day out.

Iconic attractions like the Bronx Zoo and Botanical Gardens

One of the advantages of living in the Bronx is its affordability compared to other boroughs of New York City. Housing prices in the Bronx tend to be lower than in Manhattan, Brooklyn, or Queens. This affordability makes it an attractive option for those looking to settle down or invest in real estate.

With its diverse neighborhoods and housing options, the Bronx offers a range of choices for residents.

Affordable housing prices compared to other boroughs

However, it is important to note that the Bronx does face some challenges. It has the highest violent crime rate among all the boroughs of New York City. While efforts have been made to improve safety, it is crucial for residents and visitors to stay aware of their surroundings and take necessary precautions.

Being mindful of personal safety and staying informed about local developments can help mitigate any potential risks.

Highest violent crime rate in NYC

Another aspect to consider is the transportation infrastructure in the Bronx. While it is well connected to other parts of the city through subway lines, it does have fewer options compared to other boroughs. This can sometimes result in longer commute times or limited accessibility to certain areas.

However, the Bronx does have an extensive bus network that helps residents get around and reach their desired destinations.

Fewer subway lines than other boroughs

#5 Staten Island

Staten Island, the fifth borough of New York City, offers a unique blend of suburban living and urban amenities. It is known for its serene neighborhoods, lush parks, and friendly community.

Most suburban feel of all boroughs

Staten Island stands out among the five boroughs of New York City due to its distinctly suburban atmosphere. With its tree-lined streets, spacious homes, and abundance of green spaces, it provides a tranquil escape from the bustling city life.

Residents can enjoy a slower pace of life while still having easy access to all the conveniences of a major metropolis.

Free ferry connection to Manhattan

One of the major advantages of living in Staten Island is the free ferry connection to Manhattan. The Staten Island Ferry, which operates 24/7, offers breathtaking views of the Statue of Liberty, Ellis Island, and the iconic Manhattan skyline.

Commuters can enjoy a scenic ride while avoiding the usual traffic congestion often associated with other boroughs.

Lots of families and owner-occupied housing

Staten Island is a popular choice for families looking for a safe and welcoming community. The borough boasts a high percentage of owner-occupied housing, making it an attractive option for those who want to put down roots and invest in their own homes.

The abundance of parks, playgrounds, and top-rated schools also adds to its appeal for families.

Long commute times into Manhattan by ferry or transit

While the Staten Island Ferry provides a convenient mode of transportation, the commute time from Staten Island to Manhattan can be longer compared to other boroughs. The ferry ride itself takes around 25 minutes, but the additional transit time to reach other parts of Manhattan can significantly increase the total commute time.

However, many residents find the scenic journey and peaceful surroundings worth the extra travel time.

Least access to subway lines

Unlike the other boroughs, Staten Island has limited access to subway lines. The Staten Island Railway serves as the primary mode of public transportation within the borough, connecting residents to the ferry terminal and other neighborhoods.

However, for those who rely on subway lines to commute to other parts of the city, this can be a drawback. It’s important to consider transportation options when deciding to live in Staten Island.

Conclusion

While Manhattan offers world-class entertainment, arts and dining, the high housing prices push it out of reach for many New Yorkers. For more affordable homes and still great amenities, Brooklyn, Queens and the Bronx are solid options. However, Staten Island’s remoteness makes it less desirable overall. By weighing factors like affordability, transportation, culture, and safety, Manhattan edges out the competition as the #1 borough in New York City.